Fall Creek Homes under $200,000

Fall Creek Homes under $200,000

Welcome to Fall Creek, Indiana—a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Hamilton County that perfectly blends suburban charm with the vibrancy of city life. Known for its friendly community and picturesque landscapes, Fall Creek offers residents a serene escape while still being just a stone’s throw away from the bustling city of Indianapolis.

One of the most appealing aspects of this delightful region is its affordability. For homebuyers looking to invest in their future without breaking the bank, Fall Creek boasts a variety of homes priced under $200,000. This makes it an ideal destination for first-time buyers, young families, or those seeking a cozy retreat without compromising on quality. Here, you can find charming single-family homes, well-maintained townhouses, and even quaint bungalows—all offering excellent value for your investment.

In addition to its affordable housing options, Fall Creek is known for its excellent schools, lush parks, and a strong sense of community. Residents enjoy a range of recreational activities, from hiking and biking trails to local festivals that celebrate the area’s rich culture. The proximity to major highways ensures that commuting to Indianapolis for work or leisure is both convenient and quick.

Whether you’re searching for your first home or looking to downsize, Fall Creek invites you to explore its diverse real estate offerings. Discover the perfect blend of comfort, community, and affordability in this charming Indiana locale, where your dream home awaits!

Newest Fall Creek Homes under $200,000

890 Columbia Avenue, Middletown
$134,900
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Discover the charm of 890 Columbia AVE in MIDDLETOWN, IN, a delightful single-family residence built in 1900. This inviting home, spanning 1000 square feet, is ready for you to move in and begin your next chapter. With two comfortable bedrooms, this residence provides ample private space. Step out onto the welcoming porch, an ideal spot for quiet mornings or relaxed evenings. Buyer and buyer's agent to rely on own measurements.

890 Columbia Avenue, Middletown

Listing courtesy of Christina Boyland. Rhodes Realty, LLC
905 Slack Drive, Anderson
$190,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Put your name on this mailbox @ 905 Slack DR in Fall Creek Heights Addition. A very loved and maintained brick ranch built in 1957. This charming home is ready for you to move in and begin your next chapter. The heart of this home is its spacious family room, featuring a welcoming fireplace that promises cozy evenings. The room is further elevated by a distinctive coffered ceiling and built-in shelves. Choose to place your dining area in this family room or the kitchen. All three bedrooms provides the warmth and classic appeal of hardwood flooring, adding a touch of timeless elegance. No fighting over bathroom time with the full hall bathroom and a half bath too! The one car attached garage holds the space for laundry and offers storage. The back yard is spacious with mature trees plus a shed for your lawn equipment. Just a home ready for it's next owners. Close to shopping and in Pendleton school district too!

905 Slack Drive, Anderson

Listing courtesy of Diane Wilson. RE/MAX Real Estate Solutions
118 N 8th Street, Middletown
$125,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Welcome home to this adorable, move-in ready 2-bedroom, 1-bath cottage located right in the heart of Middletown! If you love local traditions, you'll fall in love with having a front-row seat to the annual parade, watch the festivities and catch candy right from your own beautiful covered front porch, making memories for years to come. Inside, the home is packed with character, featuring a warm shiplap accent wall, a remarkably spacious kitchen and dining combo, and a full bath complete with a deep soaking tub. The main level offers comfortable living, while the basement provides valuable extra storage space. Step outside to enjoy a private, fully fenced backyard, a detached garage, and mature trees that offer the perfect balance of shade and sunshine. With unbelievably low property taxes, this home presents an incredible, affordable opportunity to stop renting and own a slice of Middletown charm!

118 N 8th Street, Middletown

Listing courtesy of Lauren Coons. The Stewart Home Group
124 N Main Street, Pendleton
$190,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Imagine 124 N Main St, recently updated with a new HVAC system for enhanced comfort. Inside, a neutral color paint scheme creates a versatile backdrop, and the primary bathroom includes double sinks for added convenience. The kitchen features all stainless steel appliances complemented by an accent backsplash. The exterior provides a fenced in backyard. This home blends modern updates with practical living. Included 100-Day Home Warranty with buyer activation

124 N Main Street, Pendleton

Listing courtesy of Shelby Farrar. Opendoor Brokerage LLC
928 S Broadway Street, Pendleton
$140,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
There is so much potential in this 4-bedroom, 2-full-bathroom home STEPS AWAY from Historic Downtown Pendleton! Bring your ideas to life in this 1896 sq ft home featuring large bedrooms, an open floor plan, vaulted ceilings, a sunroom scaling the back side of the home + much more! The kitchen offers plenty of cabinet and countertop space and opens to the living/dining area, perfect for entertaining. All appliances are included, including the W&D. The primary suite includes a walk-in closet, double sinks, a stand-up shower, and a garden tub. This home is within walking distance of downtown Pendleton to enjoy dining, shopping & entertainment- or hop on your bike and ride to Falls Park! Easy access to I69 and SR36/SR9. South Madison/Pendleton Schools. Don't miss this opportunity at an excellent price point for the location! Come check out the possibilities this home has to offer you. Water heater has been replaced October 2026.

928 S Broadway Street, Pendleton

Listing courtesy of Steve Slavin. Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
1318 Cottage Avenue, Middletown
$134,900
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Discover 1318 Cottage AVE, a meticulously maintained single-family residence in MIDDLETOWN, IN, offering 980 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space. Constructed in 1960, this inviting home presents a ready-to-move-in condition, embodying comfort and functionality. The residence features three well-proportioned bedrooms, providing ample private accommodations. A full bathroom serves these living quarters, designed for both convenience and ease of use. Spanning a single story, this property is set on a generous 9017 square foot lot. A dedicated laundry room enhances the home's practicality, streamlining daily routines. Embrace the opportunity to establish your lifestyle in this charming property! Buyer and Buyer's agent to rely on own measurements. **One of the bedrooms does attach to the primary bedroom. The primary bedroom is big enough to be divided into two rooms.

1318 Cottage Avenue, Middletown

Listing courtesy of Christina Boyland. Rhodes Realty, LLC
2791 Woodlawn Drive, Anderson
$187,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Welcome to 2791 Woodlawn Dr, a charming house located in Anderson, IN. This home has been updated with a new roof, new HVAC, all new electric service and whole house rewire, new flooring, new bath and new kitchen with quartz counters and new appliances included. Under cabinet lights in kitchen. Fresh paint outside as well.

2791 Woodlawn Drive, Anderson

Listing courtesy of Steven Koleno. Beycome Brokerage Realty LLC
6733 S Cross Street, Pendleton
$179,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Discover a charming single-family residence located at 6733 S Cross ST, PENDLETON, IN. Built in 1967, this home offers 1539 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space. This home features four well-proportioned bedrooms with a split floorplan. A full bathroom and an additional half bathroom provide convenience and functionality. Spanning a comfortable 1539 square feet on a single story, this property is designed for ease of living. The generous 4290 square foot lot provides ample outdoor space with enclosed patio and 2 car detached garage. Great price in Huntsville just outside of Pendleton. Must see!

6733 S Cross Street, Pendleton

Listing courtesy of Kurt Clements. Diverse Property Solutions Ind
269 N 8th Street, Middletown
$164,900
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
A welcoming single-family residence built in 1900, offering 1384 square feet of comfortable living space. This inviting home, ready for you to move in. This delightful residence features three well-proportioned bedrooms, with an additional 2 rooms upstairs that could be used as bedrooms. The home also includes a full bathroom, designed for everyday convenience. Spanning two stories, this bungalow-style home sits on a generous 11064 square foot lot. A charming porch invites you to enjoy quiet mornings or peaceful evenings outdoors, connecting you to the community. Imagine the possibilities and schedule your private viewing to experience this home's distinctive appeal.

269 N 8th Street, Middletown

Listing courtesy of Christina Boyland. Rhodes Realty, LLC
13255 Deception Pass, Fishers
$198,900
1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Where do I start?! This home is all you could ask for, Easy Living, Maintenance free. End Unit, Attached garage. Condition, move in ready, Great Room with Fireplace, cathedral ceilings, updates include, Windows(2025), Flooring(2023), Air Conditioning (2022), Light Fixtures, Bath, Maintenance free balcony, and more!! Price, I don't think you could find any home for less with what all this home has to offer, Location, close to Hamilton Town Center, Hospitals, Schools, I-69. Community offers a Clubhouse, Exercise area, pool, and more!! Seller is using Den as a 2nd bedroom. Take a look you will be glad you did. Note, water is included in HOA fee!

13255 Deception Pass, Fishers

Listing courtesy of Judy Shelton. F.C. Tucker Company
1317 Cottage Avenue, Middletown
$115,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Price Reduced!! Country Charm just waiting on some finishing touches! This home offers 3 bedrooms, two bathrooms and 2128 square feet of comfortable living space across 1.5 stories. From the newer flooring in the entryway and newer vinyl windows throughout this home has alot to offer. Large sun filled living room with hardwood floors, wood beams and some newer light fixtures to keep the country appeal. Spacious kitchen newer countertops. Master bedroom with tray ceiling, newer carpet and a bay window. Two additional spacious bedrooms with newer carpet and large closets. 2nd bath has been updated with a new sink, fixtures and flooring. Plenty of storage space in the 512 square feet unfinished basement! Two Car Detached Garage with electrical and Fenced in back yard! This property offers abundant outdoor potential for recreation or tranquil enjoyment.

1317 Cottage Avenue, Middletown

Listing courtesy of Aubrey Walters. eXp Realty, LLC
234 S East Street, Pendleton
$150,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Step right up, folks, and feast your eyes on 234 S East ST, a charming single-family residence in PENDLETON, IN, built way back in 1899! This delightful 1656 square foot bungalow isn't just a house; it's a ticket to a bygone era with all the modern comforts you crave. Get ready to fall head over heels for a place that's practically winking at you! Ready to start your next adventure? Come on down and see why this delightful dwelling is the perfect place to hang your hat! HUD Case#: 156-068022 IN. HUD homes are sold As-Is. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

234 S East Street, Pendleton

Listing courtesy of Michelle McGuire. Golden Rule Realty, LLC
Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative as distributed by MLS GRID.


Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker of MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some listings have been excluded from this website.


How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!