Sugar Creek Homes with Olthof Homes Builder

Sugar Creek Homes with Olthof Homes Builder

Welcome to Sugar Creek, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Cumberland, Indiana, within the charming Hancock County. This vibrant community offers the perfect blend of suburban tranquility and urban convenience, making it an ideal place for families, professionals, and retirees alike. With its lush green spaces, well-maintained parks, and friendly neighborhoods, Sugar Creek is not just a place to live; it’s a place to thrive.

One of the standout features of Sugar Creek is the exceptional homes built by Olthof Homes, a renowned builder known for their commitment to quality and craftsmanship. Each residence reflects a dedication to detail, offering modern designs, spacious layouts, and energy-efficient features that cater to today’s homeowner. Whether you’re looking for a cozy starter home or a luxurious family residence, Olthof Homes provides a variety of floor plans and styles to suit your unique lifestyle.

Living in Sugar Creek means you’ll have access to excellent schools, a plethora of shopping and dining options, and a strong sense of community. Enjoy weekend outings at local parks, engage in community events, or take a short drive to nearby Indianapolis for a taste of city life. With its welcoming atmosphere and beautiful homes, Sugar Creek is the perfect backdrop for creating lasting memories.

Discover your dream home in Sugar Creek today, and experience the exceptional quality of life that awaits you in this delightful Indiana community. With Olthof Homes, your vision of the perfect home is just a step away!

Newest Sugar Creek Homes with Olthof Homes Builder

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

7021 Lillian Place, Cumberland

Listing courtesy of Totalis Real Estate Solutions.

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Check out this great opportunity to own a nearly new home that is as clean as new construction and to make it even a better move the seller is willing to pay for a 2-1 buydown which will save you some cash! Situated on a premium pond lot, this home offers an unobstructed eastwardly view of the water, along with access to the neighborhood trail that leads to the playground. The floor plan features a spacious entry, a private office, and an open-concept kitchen, dining area, and family room. The kitchen includes all the needed appliances, an island with space for bar stools, and soft-close drawers. Upstairs, you will find a loft that provides additional living space, four bedrooms with walk-in closets, and a laundry room conveniently located near the bedrooms. The primary suite is spacious and includes a large walk-in closet. The private bath features double vanities and a shower with a tile surround. Come take a look at this well-kept home, featuring clean walls with no nail holes, a desirable location, and a covered patio where you can relax and enjoy the beautiful views.

173 Lynnette Way, Cumberland

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company.

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Welcome to the Sedona, a beautifully designed 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath two-story home offering modern comfort and timeless style. Enjoy the impressive two-story great room that fills the home with natural light, and a versatile flex room with French doors-perfect for a home office or study. The kitchen is equipped with new stainless-steel appliances, 42" cabinets, and a tankless water heater for added efficiency. An extended two-car garage provides extra storage and convenience. Thoughtfully crafted with open spaces and elegant finishes, the Sedona is a home built for both everyday living and memorable gatherings.

7072 Jackson Drive, Cumberland

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company.

Start Your Search

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative

Janko Realty Group

Why Janko Realty Group Local experts. Proven results. Real relationships. Buying or selling a home in Hendricks County isn't a transaction — it's one of the biggest financial and emotional decisions your family will make. That's why people here keep choosing Janko Realty Group. We're an independently owned team based in downtown Plainfield with more than 850 successful transactions across Avon, Brownsburg, Plainfield, Danville and greater Indianapolis. Out of nearly 10,000 agents in the MIBOR REALTOR® Association, we rank in the top 1%. But the number we're proudest of is 235+ five-star Google reviews — because that one gets earned one family at a time. What that means for you: We actually live here. Schools, builders, commute times, which streets flood and which subdivisions hold value — we know it because it's our backyard, not a search result. Pricing built on data, not hope. Sellers get a real number and a strategy. Buyers get an honest read on whether a home is worth what they're asking. Marketing that gets your home seen. Professional photography, video, and the reach of a brand people in this county already recognize. A full team, not one busy agent. Someone is always available to show a home, answer a call, or catch a problem before it costs you. Straight answers, even the unpopular ones. You'll always know where you stand. Let's talk about what's next for you. No pressure, no obligation — just a conversation.

Learn More

Tony Janko

Tony Janko — REALTOR®, Broker/Owner Who is Tony Janko?Tony Janko is a REALTOR® and Broker/Owner of Janko Realty Group in Plainfield, Indiana, with 18 years in real estate and more than 850 completed transactions across Hendricks County and greater Indianapolis. Tony has lived in Central Indiana for over 35 years and in Avon for 30 of them. When he talks about how a subdivision has held up, which builders did good work, or how a corridor has changed, he isn't reciting market data — he watched it happen from inside the community. Why He Started Janko Realty Group Tony spent the first part of his career as a top-performing agent at national brands. He did well there, and he also saw the ceiling clearly: large franchise systems are built to process volume, and the client experience gets standardized down to whatever the system can support at scale. Exceeding a client's expectations — not just meeting them — took more latitude than a national model allowed. In 2021, he and Toni Eads opened Janko Realty Group as an independent brokerage so they could set their own standard. Independence means the marketing budget, the service decisions, and the accountability all sit with the two owners, in the county they sell in. There is no corporate policy to hide behind and no one else to escalate to. That is the point. Eighteen years and 800 transactions is a specific kind of education. It means Tony has worked a rising market, a falling one, and the flat stretches in between; has seen how appraisal gaps, financing failures, and inspection standoffs actually resolve; and can tell you early which deals are likely to close and which ones need a different plan. What Tony Specializes In Seller representation and listings — pricing strategy, pre-list preparation, and marketing campaigns Buyer representation — including move-up buyers and relocating families New construction — builder contracts, spec vs. custom decisions, construction timelines, and third-party inspections Simultaneous sell-and-buy transactions — coordinating two closings so you're not homeless or double-mortgaged Luxury homes in the $350,000 to $1 million range How Tony Works With Sellers Tony treats a listing as a marketing campaign with a deadline. Pricing comes from current MLS data — days on market, absorption, closed comparables — rather than from an owner's hope or an agent's guess at the listing appointment. Preparation comes before photography, because the first ten days on market are when buyer attention and negotiating leverage peak, and they don't come back. From there it's exposure and negotiation: professional photography and video, MLS and portal syndication, direct marketing to the firm's buyer database and agent network, and offer terms negotiated with a clear view of what each concession costs your net proceeds. "We literally listed on a Friday, and received an offer that following Monday (Not making this up). They knocked the marketing out of the ball park which made all the difference!"— Joel Harris, Google review How Tony Works With Buyers For buyers, most of Tony's value shows up before the offer. He'll tell you what a subdivision's resale history looks like, which builder put the house up and how their work has held, and whether the price is defensible or aspirational. Thirty years in Avon means a lot of that comes from memory rather than research. He is particularly active in new construction, where the risks are different — a builder's contract is written by the builder's attorney, the timeline will move, and the walkthrough matters more than anything on the brochure. "We needed to sell our previous home while going through the process of building our next home and Tony made sure the timelines on both matched up so that it was practically an stress-free experience! ... he also came with us to meet with the project manager and inspectors for our new construction home."— Emily Schweitzer, Google review The Team Tony co-owns Janko Realty Group with fellow REALTOR® and Broker/Owner Toni Eads. Since opening in 2021, the firm has helped 850+ families, closed 81 homes in 2025 totaling $33,495,960, holds over 235 five-star Google reviews, and ranks in the top 1% of nearly 10,000 agents in the MIBOR REALTOR® Association — the #1 real estate team in Hendricks County by MLS production volume and public review count. Frequently Asked Questions How long has Tony Janko been in real estate?Tony Janko has been in real estate for 18 years and has completed more than 850 transactions in Hendricks County and greater Indianapolis. He is a REALTOR® and Broker/Owner of Janko Realty Group. When was Janko Realty Group founded?Tony Janko and Toni Eads opened Janko Realty Group in 2021 as an independent brokerage in Plainfield, Indiana, after both spent years as agents with national brands. Does Tony Janko live in the area he sells?Yes. Tony has lived in Central Indiana for more than 35 years and in Avon, Indiana for 30 years. What areas does Tony Janko serve?Tony serves Avon, Brownsburg, Plainfield, Danville, and communities throughout Hendricks County and the greater Indianapolis area. Does Tony Janko work with new construction buyers?Yes. New construction is a core part of Tony's practice, including builder contract review, construction timelines, third-party inspections, and coordinating the sale of a current home against a build completion date. How do I contact Tony Janko?Call or text Tony at 317.414.9355, or email Tony@JankoRealtyGroup.com. Janko Realty Group is located at 234 E Main St, Suite 109, Plainfield, IN 46168. Work With Tony Whether you're preparing to list, starting a build, or just weighing whether this is the right year to move, the first conversation carries no obligation. Tony Janko, REALTOR® · Broker/Owner, Janko Realty Group317.414.9355 · Tony@JankoRealtyGroup.com234 E Main St, Suite 109, Plainfield, IN 46168

Learn More

Toni Eads

Toni Eads — REALTOR®, Broker/Owner Who is Toni Eads?Toni Eads is a REALTOR® and Broker/Owner of Janko Realty Group in Plainfield, Indiana, with more than 22 years of experience representing buyers and sellers throughout Hendricks County and greater Indianapolis. A lifelong Central Indiana resident, Toni has spent her entire career in one market — and it shows in the details. She knows the builders behind the subdivisions in Avon, how inventory moves through Brownsburg in a given season, and what a Plainfield home is genuinely worth on the day you ask, not what a website estimated last quarter. She is also an owner of the firm. When you hire Toni, you are working directly with a principal of the business, not an associate assigned to your file. What Toni Specializes In Seller representation and listings — pricing strategy, pre-list preparation, and marketing Buyer representation — including first-time buyers and move-up buyers New construction — builder contracts, walkthroughs, and construction timelines Relocation — buyers moving into Hendricks County from out of state or out of market Luxury homes in the $350,000 to $1 million range How Toni Works With Buyers Buying a home involves a hundred small decisions, and most of them arrive faster than a first-time buyer expects. Toni's approach is to explain each one before it becomes urgent — what a contingency actually protects, what an inspection finding really costs, and when a property is worth competing for. That patience is the single most consistent theme in her reviews. First-time buyers describe her as someone who made an unfamiliar process feel manageable, and who stayed reachable at hours most agents don't. "My husband and I were first time home buyers and Toni was suggested to us by our mortage broker. I wanted someone trustworthy who really had out best interest at heart. Well, that is exactly who Toni is."— Ryleigh Taylor, Google review How Toni Works With Sellers For sellers, Toni's work begins before the listing goes live: an honest assessment of price supported by current MLS data, and specific guidance on which updates and staging decisions will return money at closing and which will not. Once the property is on the market, she manages the campaign and the negotiation — offer terms, appraisal gaps, financing contingencies, and inspection responses — with a clear view of what each concession is actually worth to your bottom line. "Toni's real estate knowledge, negotiating skills, and ethics are also top-notch. She and Tony provide excellent, timely communication throughout the process and have continued to follow-up after the closings."— J Norman, Google review What Her Clients Say Toni's reviews return to the same three qualities: she answers, she tells you the truth, and she treats clients like family. "They went out of their way to make our sale happen. Always answering questions at all hours of the day and night... They treated us like family. If you want a realtor who truly cares, call Toni Eads at Janko Realty."— Todd Richardson, Google review "Toni was wonderful to work with. She's kind, professional, responsive, knowledgeable and so very helpful. She definitely has her clients' best interest at heart."— Tammy Johnson, Google review The Team Behind Her Toni co-owns Janko Realty Group with fellow REALTOR® and Broker/Owner Tony Janko. Together they bring more than 35 years of combined experience to the Hendricks County market. The firm has helped 850+ families, closed 81 homes in 2025 totaling $33,495,960, holds 238 five-star Google reviews, and ranks in the top 1% of nearly 10,000 agents in the MIBOR REALTOR® Association — the #1 real estate team in Hendricks County by MLS production volume and public review count. Frequently Asked Questions How long has Toni Eads been a real estate agent?Toni Eads has worked in real estate for more than 22 years, all of it in the Central Indiana market. She is a REALTOR® and Broker/Owner of Janko Realty Group. What areas does Toni Eads serve?Toni serves Avon, Brownsburg, Plainfield, Danville, and communities throughout Hendricks County and the greater Indianapolis area. Does Toni Eads work with first-time home buyers?Yes. First-time buyers are a significant portion of Toni's business, and her reviews consistently cite her patience in explaining the process to buyers who have never purchased before. How do I contact Toni Eads?Call or text Toni at 317.430.1608, or email ToniEads@JankoRealtyGroup.com. Janko Realty Group is located at 234 E Main St, Suite 109, Plainfield, IN 46168. Work With Toni Whether you are preparing to list, starting a search, or simply trying to decide whether this is the right year to move, the first conversation carries no obligation. Toni Eads, REALTOR® · Broker/Owner, Janko Realty Group317.430.1608 · ToniEads@JankoRealtyGroup.com234 E Main St, Suite 109, Plainfield, IN 46168

Learn More

View Sugar Creek Home Values

Browse Sugar Creek Homes by Property Type

Browse Sugar Creek Homes by Basement

Browse Sugar Creek Homes by Builder