Sugar Creek Homes for Sale

Sugar Creek Homes for Sale

Welcome to Sugar Creek, Indiana – a hidden gem that perfectly balances small-town charm with modern conveniences. Nestled amidst the serene landscapes of Indiana, Sugar Creek offers a tranquil lifestyle while being just a short drive from the vibrant cities of Indianapolis and Lafayette. This picturesque community is known for its friendly atmosphere, excellent schools, and a strong sense of community, making it an ideal place for families, retirees, and everyone in between.

As you explore the homes for sale in Sugar Creek, you'll discover a diverse array of properties that cater to various tastes and budgets. From charming single-family homes with spacious yards to contemporary townhouses that offer low-maintenance living, there's something here for everyone. Many of these homes feature beautiful architectural details, modern amenities, and are situated in peaceful neighborhoods, perfect for enjoying the outdoors and connecting with neighbors.

Living in Sugar Creek means embracing an active lifestyle. Residents can take advantage of the numerous parks, walking trails, and recreational facilities that the area has to offer. Whether you enjoy hiking, biking, or simply unwinding in nature, you'll find plenty of opportunities to explore the great outdoors.

Additionally, Sugar Creek boasts a rich cultural scene with local events, farmers' markets, and community gatherings that foster a strong sense of belonging. With its welcoming spirit and beautiful surroundings, Sugar Creek is not just a place to live; it’s a place to call home. Don’t miss the chance to find your dream home in this enchanting community!

Newest Sugar Creek Homes for Sale

$199,900
4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Welcome to 111 W Church St in Thorntown, where small-town charm meets the very serious business of finding your next home! This property is ready for its next chapter and offers the perfect opportunity to put down roots, spread out, and make yourself at home. Conveniently located in the heart of Thorntown, you'll be close to the kind of local amenities that make small-town living so appealing. Whether you're looking for a place to call home, a fresh project, or simply somewhere new to spread your wings. Come see this one today!

111 W Church Street, Thorntown

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company.

$282,500
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Set on 0.62 acres in New Palestine, this well-maintained brick ranch offers the space, privacy, and single-level living buyers are looking for. With 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, and 1,577 square feet, the home features a spacious living room anchored by a wood-burning fireplace, an eat-in kitchen with breakfast bar, and a welcoming foyer. The primary suite includes a walk-in closet and private bath with a separate tub and shower, while two additional bedrooms provide flexibility for family, guests, or a home office. Outside, enjoy a large fully fenced backyard with plenty of room to entertain, garden, play, or simply relax beneath the mature trees. A mini barn adds convenient extra storage, and the attached finished 2-car garage provides even more functionality. With no HOA and more than half an acre, there is room to spread out without giving up convenient access to New Palestine and the Southern Hancock County school system. Whether you're drawn to the classic brick exterior, generous yard, cozy fireplace, or easy ranch-style floor plan, this property offers a comfortable place to call home with space both inside and out.

5311 W 300 S, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Mark Dietel Realty, LLC.

$254,900
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
In a quiet neighborhood in Thorntown, you'll find this perfect home. Offering nearly 1100 sq ft of living space that is updated and ready for you to enjoy. The kitchen is thoughtfully equipped with a functional island, providing both workspace and a casual dining area. Among the three inviting bedrooms, one stands out with a distinct accent wall, adding a touch of personality and character to the space. There is a lot of 'new' here, all in last three years. Improvements include the asphalt driveway, Leaf Guard gutter and downspout system, attic insulation, garage door and opener, a new water softener, as well as a painting refresh and new flooring. Beyond the interior, this home offers a large private yard, perfect for outdoor enjoyment and relaxation, which you can access through the extra-large sunroom. An attached garage provides convenience and secure parking, and a welcoming porch invites you to unwind. For added practicality, a dedicated laundry room simplifies household chores. Thorntown has much to offer, and location is Western Boone schools district.

322 Oak Street, Thorntown

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams-Morrison.

$339,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Completely Renovated Ranch on 1 Acre! Enjoy the best of both worlds with this beautifully remodeled home nestled on a spacious 1 acre lot just on the edge of town! Step inside to a brand new kitchen featuring soft close cabinetry, stunning quartz countertops, and new SS appliances. Extensive updates include a new 200 amp electrical panel, new plumbing, new flooring throughout the home, an updated gravel driveway, and more! With thoughtful design from top to bottom and plenty of outdoor space to enjoy, this move in ready property offers the perfect blend of modern comfort, country charm, and a convenient location. Don't miss your opportunity to make this refreshed home your own!

6615 W State Road 47, Thorntown

Listing courtesy of Branch Realty.

$165,000
1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Tired of renting? Considering downsizing? Ready for your own place to call home or possible investment rental? This new renovated home offers a manageable .45 acres, with newly installed windows, new maintenance free vinyl plank flooring, new trim and paint, new kitchen cabinets and countertop, new Mr Cool mini split AC with heat pump providing efficiency for utility expenses, newer water heater, newer roof, brand new ATL dosing septic system and new main line installed, yard has been freshly seeded, unfinished basement for additional storage needs and detached garage. Check it out, see for yourself.

6966 W Lora Drive, Boggstown

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company.

$449,900
5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths
Nearly 3,600 sq ft, 5 bedrooms, 4.5 baths and a layout that offers an impressive amount of flexibility! Built in 2022, this Copperstone home features a main-level bedroom suite with its own full bath and walk-in closet, plus a separate office with French doors. The heart of the home is the open-concept kitchen, dining and living area featuring quartz countertops, a large center island, stainless steel appliances, abundant cabinetry, walk-in pantry and a spacious living room with fireplace. Upstairs, a large loft provides another versatile living space, while the oversized primary suite stands out with a tray ceiling, generous walk-in closet and private bath featuring dual vanities and an oversized tiled shower with bench. Three additional upstairs bedrooms, multiple full baths and a conveniently located second-floor laundry provide plenty of additional space throughout. Outside, the fully fenced backyard offers room to spread out along with a gazebo-covered patio area ideal for relaxing or entertaining. Additional highlights include a 3-car garage, main-level mudroom/drop zone and covered front porch. Located in New Palestine's Copperstone community with neighborhood pool and playground amenities, this home delivers the space, functionality and newer construction buyers are looking for. Come see just how much 2447 S Copperstone Dr has to offer!

2447 S Copperstone Drive, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Steve Lew Real Estate Group, LLC.

$798,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths
Tucked away on a beautifully landscaped one-acre cul-de-sac lot in New Palestine's sought-after Fox Cove, this custom-built Dave Sego Builders home is the kind of property that stands apart for its quality, character, and 6 CAR GARAGE! With an all-brick exterior, mature trees, an exceptionally long concrete driveway, and impeccable curb appeal, this home has been lovingly maintained inside and out and offers the perfect blend of timeless style and modern functionality. Inside, you'll find two levels of beautifully appointed living space plus a mostly finished basement, offering 4 bedrooms, 3 full baths, and 1 half bath. The floor plan provides plenty of room for everyday living, entertaining, working from home, and growing into the home for years to come. And then there's the garage - not one, not two, not three, but SIX garage spaces! The newer garage is heated and cooled, creating an incredible flex space for car enthusiasts, hobbyists, a workshop, storage, or whatever you can dream up. Above the garage is a second living area with its own private entrance from the garage, providing endless possibilities for a home office, recreation room, studio, guest space, or additional living quarters. The home has also been thoughtfully refreshed, including new LED lighting throughout the upstairs, new LVP flooring in the bathrooms and upstairs laundry room, updated hardware on bathroom sinks and doors, and numerous additional improvements that make this home feel fresh while preserving its classic character. With three HVAC systems, exceptional garage space, generous living areas, an all-brick exterior, whole house Generac system, and a private cul-de-sac setting, this is a rare opportunity to own a custom home that offers both the craftsmanship of yesterday and the functionality buyers are looking for today. Quality construction. Exceptional space. A remarkable lot. And six garages. This is one you'll want to see in person.

7437 W Banton Circle, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Home Bound Real Estate LLC.

$364,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Well Maintained 3 BR 2 Bath on 1.22 Acres. Over 2700 sq ft home has living room and large loft. Bonus room over garage, great for office/rec room (heated/air conditioning). Large ceiling to floor stone fireplace. Multiple wood decks with access off bedrooms. New roof 2021, HAVC 2018, All appliances 2021. Property has municipal water/sewer. Large 2 garage with carport. Like new storage shed. No HOA. This is a unique property that has been very well maintained! Great area with New Palestine schools. Seller will pay 3% Buyer closing cost and or buy interest rate down.

7022 W Ivy Lane, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Assist-2-Sell.

$458,995
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Photos are of the same floor plan; finishes, features, and available options may vary. This proposed Eisenhower floor plan in Willow Ridge offers the opportunity to build a thoughtfully designed ranch-style home with modern comfort, functional design, and the peace of mind of new construction backed by a builder warranty. The main level showcases a bright, open-concept layout where the kitchen, nook, and great room flow seamlessly together, creating an inviting space for both everyday living and entertaining. The kitchen serves as the heart of the home, featuring a center island, ample cabinetry, and convenient access to the adjacent dining nook and spacious great room. Privately situated at the rear of the home, the primary suite offers a relaxing retreat complete with an en-suite bath, walk-in closet, and direct access to the laundry room. Two additional bedrooms and a full bath provide flexible space for family, guests, a home office, or hobbies. The full unfinished basement offers exceptional storage potential and opportunities for future expansion. Additional highlights include a spacious 3-car garage, covered front entry, and convenient main-level living throughout. Located in Willow Ridge, residents enjoy easy access to Interstate 465, U.S. 52, and major roadways for a quick commute to Indianapolis. Nearby shopping and dining destinations include New Towne Square and New Palestine Plaza, while outdoor recreation opportunities can be found at Sugar Creek Township Park and local walking trails. Within the community, a charming playground and serene pond views enhance the neighborhood setting. As a proposed new construction home, this is an opportunity to personalize selections and build a home that fits your lifestyle while enjoying contemporary design, efficiency, and the added peace of mind of builder warranty coverage. Learn more today!

4721 Black Willow Way, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Ridgeline Realty, LLC.

$340,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
This is one of those properties you simply don't find every day. Situated on an acre along Buck Creek, this exceptionally well-maintained brick ranch offers space, character, and features that are hard to duplicate-all with an Indianapolis address and New Palestine schools. Inside, the home has a unique, functional layout with a huge living room, fireplace, spacious kitchen and dining area, three bedrooms, and a generously sized primary bedroom with walk-in closet. The full walk-out basement provides an incredible amount of additional usable space and storage with direct access to the backyard. Outside is where this property really sets itself apart. A large back deck overlooks the wooded, secluded setting, creating the perfect spot for morning coffee, cookouts, private gatherings, or evenings with friends and family. The backyard offers plenty of room to spread out, with picnic areas beneath the trees, Buck Creek along the property, and a paved walking and biking trail just beyond. Multiple sheds and outbuildings provide room for hobbies, equipment, and storage, while the oversized detached garage is a dream for anyone who loves cars or needs serious workshop space-even featuring an oil/service pit for working underneath vehicles. Mature trees and landscaping add to the privacy while shopping, dining, and everyday conveniences remain close by. If you've been looking for more space, more privacy, and a property with features you simply can't find in a typical subdivision, this one deserves a closer look.

167 Buck Creek Road, Indianapolis

Listing courtesy of Ever Real Estate, LLC.

$375,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Space to enjoy inside and out at 4732 S Grassy Ct in New Palestine. Situated on approximately .60 acres, this 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath ranch offers 1,716 square feet of comfortable single-level living with a layout designed for everyday functionality and easy entertaining. Inside, you'll find inviting living spaces with plenty of room to gather, unwind, and make the home your own. The three-bedroom layout provides flexibility beyond traditional sleeping spaces, with options for a home office, guest room, hobby space, or whatever best fits your needs. Two full bathrooms plus an additional half bath add everyday convenience. The garage is heated and has great workshop space. Outside, the generous lot gives this property another dimension entirely. With more than half an acre, there's room to enjoy the outdoors, entertain, garden, play, or simply appreciate having additional space around you. An attached garage adds parking and storage, while the ranch-style floor plan keeps everyday living comfortably on one level. For buyers searching for a ranch home in New Palestine with a large lot, flexible living space, and room to enjoy both indoors and out, 4732 S Grassy Ct deserves a closer look.

4732 S Grassy Court, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Ever Real Estate, LLC.

$329,995
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Photos are of the same floor plan; finishes and features may vary. Welcome to this beautifully designed Bradford floor plan by Arbor Homes in the peaceful Westfall Place community, offering the perfect blend of modern comfort and small-town charm. Projected completion is late October 2026. Enjoy the peace of mind and confidence that comes with brand new construction, thoughtfully built with today's lifestyle in mind. This single-story home features 3 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, and an open concept layout that enhances both everyday living and entertaining. Enjoy the outstanding curb appeal of the desirable front elevation C, including brick and a covered front porch. Inside, the kitchen serves as the heart of the home with a large center island, ample cabinet space, and seamless flow into the great room, creating an inviting space for gathering with family and friends. The spacious great room opens to a covered patio, providing the perfect setting for relaxing or enjoying the outdoors. A versatile flex space with French doors, located at the front of the home, offers possibilities of an office, formal dining, or hobby space, allowing you to customize the home to fit your lifestyle. The private primary suite provides a comfortable retreat with a tray ceiling and generous walk-in closet, and an ensuite bathroom with dual vanities and spacious shower, while two additional bedrooms and a second full bath offer flexibility for family and guests. A dedicated laundry room adds everyday convenience and functionality. Nestled in a serene setting, Westfall Place features scenic pond views, walking trails, open green spaces, a picnic shelter, and a playground, all while providing easy access to local shops, dining, community events, and nearby recreational opportunities. With convenient connections to IN-47 and surrounding areas, this home delivers a lifestyle that balances quiet living with everyday accessibility. Learn more today!

6019 Whitney Street, Thorntown

Listing courtesy of Ridgeline Realty, LLC.

Start Your Search

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative